Ms L Edgar v Scottish Water

EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS (SCOTLAND) Case No: 4104453/2023 Held in Glasgow on 14 – 17 October 2025 Deliberations: 10, 20 and 21 November 2025 Employment Judge D Hoey Ms L Edgar Claimant Represented by: Mr R Clark - Solicitor Scottish Water Respondent Represented by: Mr M McLaughlin - Solicitor

JUDGMENT OF THE EMPLOYMENT TRIBUANL The claim is ill founded and it is dismissed.

REASONS

1. The claimant presented a claim for victimisation. Following a preliminary hearing and further discussions with the parties a large number of the detriments were withdrawn and the claim was focused. The Hearing had been fixed to determined liability only. Evidence

2. The parties had produced a joint bundle of 368 pages (which included a small number of additional documents added during the Hearing). The Tribunal heard evidence from the claimant, Ms T McArthur (a colleague of the claimant who was a trade union official from whom the claimant, herself a trade union steward, took advice), Ms G Reid (the claimant’s line manager, whose conduct the claimant re...